Where to Sell Sports Memorabilia in NYC?

Looking to sell your sports memorabilia in NYC? Here are the best places to do it!

Checkout this video:



Whether you’re a Yankees fan or die-hard Mets supporter, if you have old sports memorabilia taking up space in your home, you may be wondering where to sell it. Whether it’s an autographed baseball, an old programs from Yankee Stadium, or tickets to a historic game, sports memorabilia can be valuable.

Fortunately, there are a few options for selling sports memorabilia in NYC. Below, we outline some of the best places to sell sports memorabilia in NYC.

Christie’s Auction House
One of the most well-known auction houses in the world, Christie’s has a dedicated department for selling sports memorabilia. Located on the Upper East Side of Manhattan, Christie’s offers free appraisals for sporting items and holds regular auctions throughout the year. Some of the most valuable pieces of sports memorabilia sold through Christie’s include a Honus Wagner baseball card (which sold for $2.8 million) and Muhammad Ali’s boxing gloves (which went for $106,800).

Heritage Auctions
If you’re looking to sell high-end sports memorabilia, Heritage Auctions is another great option. Headquartered in Dallas, Texas, Heritage Auctions has an office in Midtown Manhattan and offers free appraisals for potential sellers. In addition to regular auctions throughout the year, Heritage Auctions also offers private sales and consignment services. Notable items that have been sold through Heritage Auctions include a Babe Ruth New York Yankees contract (sold for $3.7 million) and a Muhammad Ali fight-worn robe (which went for $956,000).

SCP Auctions
Founded in 1986,SCP Auctions is one of the leading auctioneers of vintage sports cards and memorabilia. With offices in California and New York City, SCP Auctions regularly holds public and private sales throughout the year. In addition to live auctions, SCP Auctions also offers online bidding through its website. Recent notable sales from SCP Auctions include a Honus Wagner T206 baseball card (which went for $3.12 million) and a Michael Jordan game-worn jersey (sold for $480,000).

The Best Places to Sell Sports Memorabilia in NYC

Whether you’re looking to get rid of some old sports memorabilia or you’re trying to start a collection, you’ll need to know where to go in New York City. There are many options available for both buying and selling sports memorabilia, so it’s important to know the ins and outs of the market before making a purchase or sale. In this article, we’ll give you an overview of the best places to buy and sell sports memorabilia in NYC.


Lelands is the world’s largest sports memorabilia company and has been in business since 1985. They offer appraisals, auctions, and private sales, and they have an extensive online database of past auction prices realized. They are located in New York City but serve clients worldwide.

Steiner Sports is another large sports memorabilia company that is based in New York. They offer appraisals and private sales, as well as corporate sales and events planning. Steiner Sports has an extensive network of athlete relationships and their website includes a price guide for many items.

Heritage Auctions is a global auction house with locations in Dallas, New York, Beverly Hills, San Francisco, and more. They offer free appraisals for items valued over $5,000 and their sports department holds several large auctions each year that feature sports memorabilia.

Gotta Have It! Collectibles is a New York–based company that specializes in high-end collectibles. In addition to appraisals and private sales, they also offer consignment services. Their website includes a database of past auction prices realized.

Heritage Auctions

Heritage Auctions is one of the world’s largest auctioneers of rare and collectible items. Based in Dallas, Texas, Heritage Auctions has offices across the United States, as well as in Hong Kong, London, and Paris.

Heritage Auctions holds sports memorabilia auctions several times a year, with their next auction taking place in February 2020. Items that have been sold through Heritage Auctions in the past include a baseball signed by Babe Ruth that sold for $130,000, a Joe DiMaggio rookie card that sold for $250,000, and a Honus Wagner baseball card that sold for $3.1 million.

If you’re looking to sell your sports memorabilia through an auction house, Heritage Auctions is a great option.

SCP Auctions

SCP Auctions is a leading sports auction house based in California. They offer consignment services for a wide variety of sports memorabilia, including merchandise from NYC-based teams. Their auctions are held both online and offline, giving you the option to sell your items in person or via the internet. They also provide appraisal services to help you determine the value of your memorabilia.

Steiner Sports

Steiner Sports is a memorabilia company located in New Rochelle, New York. The company was founded in 1987 by Brandon Steiner. Steiner Sports is the exclusive provider of autographed memorabilia for Yankees players and has partnerships with Bilderberg Sports Management and the New York Jets. The company also operates a store in Yankee Stadium.

Sports collectors often seek out Steiner Sports for autographed baseballs, jerseys, and other Yankees-related memorabilia. The company also offers a wide range of other sports memorabilia, including items from the NBA, NFL, NHL, and NCAA.

If you’re looking to sell your sports memorabilia, Steiner Sports is a great option. The company offers free appraisals and will purchase items outright or consign them on your behalf.

Grey Flannel Auctions

If you’re looking to sell sports memorabilia in NYC, one of the best places to start is Grey Flannel Auctions. They offer a wide range of services for buyers and sellers, and they have a good reputation in the industry. They also have an online presence, so you can reach a wider audience.

How to Get the Most Money for Your Sports Memorabilia

Sports memorabilia can be a great way to make some extra money, but it can be difficult to know where to sell it. In NYC, there are a few options for selling sports memorabilia. You can sell it online, at a consignment shop, or at a sports memorabilia store. Let’s take a look at each option.

Do Your Research

The market for sports memorabilia is always changing, so it’s important to do your research before you sell. Find out what similar items have sold for and get an idea of what the current market value is for the item you have. Once you have a general idea, you can start shopping around for potential buyers.

There are a few different options for selling sports memorabilia, and each has its own advantages and disadvantages. Pawn shops and consignment shops are usually the quickest and easiest way to get cash for your items, but you will likely only get a fraction of the item’s actual value. Online auctions can be a good option if you’re patient and are willing to let the market dictate the price, but there are no guarantees that your item will sell.

The best way to get the most money for your sports memorabilia is to find a collector or dealer who specializes in the type of item you have. These buyers are usually willing to pay more because they know the market value of the item and they are usually more interested in acquiring specific items to add to their collection. However, it can be difficult to find these buyers if you don’t know where to look.

Here are a few tips on where to sell sports memorabilia in NYC:

-Start by checking with local sports stores or collector shops. They may be interested in purchasing your item or they may be able to refer you to another collector or dealer who is interested.
-Check online classifieds websites like Craigslist or eBay. You may be able to find collectors or dealers who are looking for specific items by searching through these websites.
-Attend local sports collectible conventions or trade shows. These events bring together buyers and sellers from all over the country, so it’s a great place to find potential buyers for your items.

Find the Right Buyer

When you’re ready to sell sports memorabilia, the first step is to find the right buyer. There are many factors to consider, such as the type of item you have, its condition and whether or not the buyer is reputable.

The best way to find a buyer is to ask around. Talk to friends, family and other collectors to see if they have any recommendations. You can also check online forums and classified ads to see if anyone is looking for what you have.

Once you’ve found a few potential buyers, it’s time to compare their offers. Some buyers may be willing to pay more than others, so it’s important to get an idea of what your item is worth before you sell. You can use online resources such as eBay’s completed listings or Price Charting to get an idea of what similar items have sold for in the past.

Once you’ve chosen a buyer, be sure to get everything in writing before you make the sale. This will protect both you and the buyer in case there are any problems with the transaction.

Negotiate the Price

When it comes to sports memorabilia, the price is not always set in stone. In many cases, you can negotiate the price of your item, especially if you are selling to a private collector. However, there are a few things to keep in mind when negotiating:

-Know the value of your item: Do your research and know how much your item is worth before you start negotiating. This will help you stay firm on your price and not get taken advantage of.
-Start high: It’s always better to start high and come down in price than to start low and have to go up. This gives you room to negotiate without devaluing your item.
-Be willing to walk away: If the buyer is not willing to meet your price, be prepared to walk away from the deal. There will always be other buyers interested in your item.


We have compiled a list of the best places to sell sports memorabilia in NYC. whether you are looking for the highest prices or the most convenient location, this list has you covered.

1. Lelands Auction House
2. Heritage Auctions
3. SCP Auctions
4. Steiner Sports Memorabilia
5. sportsmemorabilia.com

Similar Posts