Where Do I Sell My Sports Cards?

Looking to sell your sports cards? Visit our blog for the latest tips on where to find the best buyers for your collection.

Checkout this video:


Have a bunch of old sports cards collecting dust in your attic? You might be surprised to learn that those cards could be worth some serious cash. In this guide, we’ll show you where to sell sports cards for the most money.

Whether you’re looking to offload a few cards or an entire collection, there are a few different options available to you. Local card shops, online marketplaces, and auction houses all offer different pros and cons, and it’s important to choose the right one depending on what you’re looking to get out of the sale.

Local Card Shops
If you’re looking for a quick and easy sale, your local card shop is probably your best bet. Most shops will give you an on-the-spot offer for your cards, and you’ll usually walk away with cash in hand. However, because they need to make a profit on their own sales, you likely won’t get top dollar for your cards at a shop. In general, expect to get between 50% and 70% of the card’s condition-dependent value.

Online Marketplaces
Selling your cards online could potentially net you more money than selling them in-person, but it will also take more time and effort on your part. The two most popular online marketplaces for sports cards are eBay and COMC (Check Out My Cards).

Auction Houses
If you have high-end cards or an extensive collection, selling at auction might be the best option for you. Heritage Auctions and PWCC Marketplace are two of the most well-known sports card auction houses.

Pawn Shops

Pawn shops are found in nearly every town and city, and they are always looking for new merchandise to sell. If you have a large collection of sports cards, or even just a few rare cards, a pawn shop may be interested in buying them from you.

The advantage of selling to a pawn shop is that it is usually a quick and easy transaction. You can simply take your cards into the shop and receive cash on the spot. The downside is that pawn shops typically offer much less than the cards are worth, so you may not get as much money as you would if you sold them to another collector or dealer.

Local Collectible Stores

Local collectible stores will likely give you the least amount of money for your sports cards. However, they can be a good option if you need to sell your cards quickly or if you do not want to deal with the hassle of shipping your cards. When selling to a local collectible store, be sure to bring your cards in a protective case and have them appraised before agreeing to a sale.

Online Auctions

There are a few things to consider when selling your sports cards online. One is the auction site you use. The two most popular options are eBay and COMC ( short for Check Out My Cards). Each has its own advantages and disadvantages.

eBay is the larger and more well-known of the two, so it usually has more potential buyers looking at your cards. However, it also charges higher fees – both for listing your items and for any sales you make. COMC doesn’t charge any listing fees, but instead takes a 10% cut of any sale you make.

Both sites have built-in shipping calculators to help you figure out how much it will cost to send your cards to the buyer. You should also factor in the cost of packaging materials when you’re pricing your items.

Another thing to consider is what kind of payment you’re willing to accept. PayPal is the most popular option, but there are others like Stripe and Skrill that you can use as well. Some buyers may only be willing to pay with certain types of payment, so it’s good to have options.

Finally, think about whether you want to offer any kind of warranty or guarantee on the items you sell. This is especially important if you’re selling high-end items that are valuable or rare. Buyers will be more likely to purchase from you if they know they can get their money back if there’s a problem with the item.

Online Marketplaces

Thanks to the internet, there are now a number of different online marketplaces where you can sell your sports cards. These platforms provide a convenient way to reach a large audience of potential buyers, and they can be a great option if you’re looking to get the most money for your cards.

Some of the most popular online marketplaces for selling sports cards include:

-eBay: One of the largest and most well-known online marketplaces, eBay is a great option for selling sports cards. You can create listings for individual cards or sets, and there are no listing fees. However, eBay does charge a final value fee (which is typically 10% of the total sale price), so be sure to take that into account when pricing your cards.

-Amazon: Amazon is another huge online marketplace that can be a great option for selling sports cards. Like eBay, Amazon has no listing fees, but they do charge a final value fee (which is typically between 8% and 15% of the total sale price). One downside to selling on Amazon is that they have stricter rules about shipping and packaging than some other platforms, so be sure to read their guidelines carefully before listing your cards.

-CardConnect: CardConnect is an online marketplace specifically for trading and selling sports cards. There are no listing fees or final value fees, so it can be a great option if you’re looking to maximize your profits. However, CardConnect does have some limitations in terms of which cards can be listed (for example, only certified authenticcards from major manufacturers are allowed), so be sure to check their guidelines before creating a listing.

-Sportscard Investor: Sportscard Investor is an online platform that allows you to buy and sell sports cards similar to how you would trade stocks on the stock market. This platform charges No Commission Fees on sales made through their site, so it’s another good option if you’re looking to keep more of the money from your card sales. However, Sportscard Investor does have a monthly subscription fee of $9.99 in order to use their site.


In conclusion, there are many options available for selling sports cards. You can choose to sell online, through a brick-and-mortar store, or through a private sale. There are also many different grading companies that can provide you with an accurate appraisal of your cards. When selling your cards, it is important to do your research in order to get the best price possible.

Similar Posts